California Civil Code §§ 5900–5965
The two gates before a lawsuit
A disqualified candidate has to be told how to appeal, and the appeal route the statute names is this one. Behind it sits a second gate: an enforcement action for declaratory, injunctive or writ relief may not be filed at all until alternative dispute resolution has been offered and either refused or completed.
Why an election law site carries this article
Section 5103(c)(2)(B) requires that a nominee who is told they do not qualify be given the basis for the disqualification and the procedure, which shall comply with Article 2 (commencing with Section 5900) of Chapter 10, by which the nominee may appeal. That is a cross-reference to this article, by number, inside the acclamation conditions. An association whose internal procedure does not satisfy § 5910 has not given a qualifying appeal route, and the acclamation condition is not met.
Civil Code § 5900 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5900.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5905 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5905.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5910 — the text
What this section used to say
Read by comparing the Legislative Counsel's biennial publications of the code, one per session. The earliest is the 2013–2014 publication, which already carries the Act in its present numbering, so changes are recorded from the publication after it onward. This matters beyond the record: § 5145 gives a member one year to challenge an election, and the text that governs is the text in force on the day it was held, not today's.
-
AB 731effective 2016-01-01
Amended by Stats. 2015, Ch. 303, Sec. 34. Effective January 1, 2016.
3 subdivisions changed · net of AB 1738, AB 731
See what changed
- A fair, reasonable, and expeditious dispute resolution procedure
shallshall, at aminimumminimum, satisfy all of the following requirements: - (e)A
resolutionwritten resolution, signed by both parties, of a dispute pursuant to theprocedure, whichprocedure that is not in conflict with the law or the governingdocuments,documents binds the association and is judicially enforceable.An agreementA written agreement, signed by both parties, reached pursuant to theprocedure, whichprocedure that is not in conflict with the law or the governingdocuments,documents binds the parties and is judicially enforceable. - (f)… and the association may explain their positions. The member and association may be assisted by an attorney or another person in explaining their positions at their own cost.
- A fair, reasonable, and expeditious dispute resolution procedure
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5910.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5910.1 — the text
What this section used to say
Read by comparing the Legislative Counsel's biennial publications of the code, one per session. The earliest is the 2013–2014 publication, which already carries the Act in its present numbering, so changes are recorded from the publication after it onward. This matters beyond the record: § 5145 gives a member one year to challenge an election, and the text that governs is the text in force on the day it was held, not today's.
-
SB 323effective 2020-01-01
Added by Stats. 2019, Ch. 848, Sec. 8. (SB 323) Effective January 1, 2020.
Added to the code by this act.
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5910.1.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5915 — the text
What this section used to say
Read by comparing the Legislative Counsel's biennial publications of the code, one per session. The earliest is the 2013–2014 publication, which already carries the Act in its present numbering, so changes are recorded from the publication after it onward. This matters beyond the record: § 5145 gives a member one year to challenge an election, and the text that governs is the text in force on the day it was held, not today's.
-
AB 731effective 2016-01-01
Amended by Stats. 2015, Ch. 303, Sec. 35. Effective January 1, 2016.
5 subdivisions changed · net of AB 1738, AB 731
See what changed
- (a)… in this section is fair, reasonable, and
expeditious,expeditious within the meaning of this article. - (b)(2)A member of an association may refuse a request to meet and confer. The association
mayshall not refuse a request to meet and confer. - (b)(4)… in an effort to resolve the dispute. The parties may be assisted by an attorney or another person at their own cost when conferring.
- (c)
AnA written agreement reached under this section binds the parties and is judicially enforceable if it is signed by both parties and both of the following conditions are satisfied: - (d)A member
mayshall not be charged a fee to participate in the process.
- (a)… in this section is fair, reasonable, and
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5915.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5920 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5920.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5925 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5925.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5930 — the text
Sources differ. Subdivision (b) reads “stated in Sections 116.220 and 116.221 of the Code of Civil Procedure” in the Legislative Counsel's database and “Section 116.220 and 116.221” in California Public Law. The text here follows the official database. Everything else reads identically in both.
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5930.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5935 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5935.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5940 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5940.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5945 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5945.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5950 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5950.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5955 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5955.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5960 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5960.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Civil Code § 5965 — the text
Reproduced verbatim from the California Legislative Counsel's published text and verified word-for-word against a second source (leginfo (Legislative Counsel official bulk code database, LAW_SECTION_TBL) · California Public Law (Public.Law)). California statutes are government edicts and carry no copyright. This is an unofficial reproduction — the official version is published by the Legislative Counsel at leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, and that version governs.
Machine-readable: /data/5965.json — the same text with its subdivision anchors, dates and sources.
Gate one: the association's own procedure
Section 5905 obliges every association to provide a fair, reasonable and expeditious procedure for resolving a dispute within the scope of § 5900, and to make it available to a member who requests it. Section 5910 sets the floor it must meet — among other things, that a member may refuse to participate, that the association may not; that the member is not charged a fee; and that a written resolution signed by both parties, where it does not conflict with the law or the governing documents, binds the association and is judicially enforceable.
An association that has adopted nothing does not escape: § 5915 supplies a default procedure, and it is specific. Either party may request a meeting to resolve the dispute in writing; a member's request obliges the board to meet; the board designates a director to meet; and an agreement reached is put in writing and signed.
The asymmetry worth knowing
Under § 5910 the member may refuse to participate in the association's internal procedure, and the association may not refuse a request from a member. The procedure is a right the member holds, not a hoop the association makes them jump through — which is the opposite of how it is usually described in governing documents.
Gate two: the Request for Resolution
Section 5930 bars an association or a member from filing an enforcement action in the superior court until alternative dispute resolution has been offered and either refused or completed. It applies where the action is solely for declaratory, injunctive or writ relief, or for that relief together with monetary damages within the small claims jurisdictional limits.
The mechanism is in § 5935: a party serves a Request for Resolution on the other, and the notice must state that the recipient has 30 days to respond or the request is deemed rejected. Where it is accepted, § 5940 gives the parties 90 days from receipt of the acceptance to complete the process unless they extend it, puts the costs on the parties, and applies the Evidence Code's mediation confidentiality to everything but arbitration. Section 5925 defines what counts: mediation, arbitration, conciliation, or another non-judicial procedure involving a neutral.
Two carve-outs in § 5930 are worth holding: it does not apply to a small claims action, and it does not apply to an assessment dispute. Neither reaches an election challenge, which is why the gate stands in front of one.
What this means for an election challenge
An action under § 5145 seeks declaratory or equitable relief — to void the result. That is squarely the kind of action § 5930 gates. So a member who believes an election was run unlawfully has a year to sue, and inside that year has first to serve a Request for Resolution and wait out a 30-day response window.
For the association that is not relief, it is a deadline. The window in which the records that would answer the complaint must still exist is the same one-year window — and the Request for Resolution is the first notice that it is running. An association that treats it as a formality has spent part of its own preparation time.
It has to be described where members look
Section 5920 requires the annual policy statement under § 5310 to include a description of the internal dispute resolution process. An association whose policy statement is silent has a procedure nobody has been told about, which is a poor answer to a nominee asking how to appeal a disqualification under § 5103.
And the article dictates the sentence
§ 5965(a) adds a second annual obligation to § 5920's, and this one supplies its own wording. The association shall annually give members a summary of this article that references it specifically, and the summary shall include the following language:
Failure of a member of the association to comply with the alternative dispute resolution requirements of Section 5930 of the Civil Code may result in the loss of the member's right to sue the association or another member of the association regarding enforcement of the governing documents or the applicable law.
§ 5965(b) says where it goes: into the annual policy statement prepared under § 5310 — the same document that must already describe the internal procedure. Two requirements, one envelope, and the second of them is a sentence the Legislature wrote out in full.
The gate does not eat the deadline
An action under § 5145 must be brought within a year. The ADR gate sits in front of it and takes time to pass — 30 days for a response, then up to 90 more if the request is accepted. Left alone, the gate would consume a third of the window.
§ 5945 stops that. If the Request for Resolution is served before the limitation period ends, the period is tolled through the § 5935 response window and, where the request is accepted, through the § 5940 completion period including any extension the parties stipulate to. The word doing the work is before: tolling protects a request served inside the year, not one served after it.
The certificate that has to be in the file
§ 5950(a): at the time an enforcement action is commenced, the party bringing it must file with the initial pleading a certificate stating that one or more of three conditions is satisfied —
- Alternative dispute resolution has been completed in compliance with the article.
- Another party to the dispute did not accept the terms offered for it.
- Preliminary or temporary injunctive relief is necessary.
The third is the escape hatch for an urgent case, and it is the only one that does not require having gone through the process. § 5950(b) supplies the consequence: failing to file the certificate is grounds for a demurrer or a motion to strike — unless the court finds that dismissing the action for non-compliance would cause substantial prejudice to one of the parties.
Two provisions that operate after the case has started
§ 5955(a): once an action is under way, the parties may by written stipulation send it to alternative dispute resolution. The action is then stayed, and during the stay it is outside the delay-reduction rules made under Government Code § 68603(c) — so a case does not get struck for sitting still while the parties are, in fact, negotiating. Costs lie where they fall, on the parties.
Refusing to negotiate becomes a number
§ 5960: in an enforcement action where fees and costs may be awarded, the court in determining the amount of the award may consider whether a party's refusal to participate in ADR before the action was reasonable. Read it with § 5975(c), which makes a fee award to the prevailing party mandatory in an action to enforce the governing documents. Whether fees are awarded is settled by who wins; how much is awarded is where an unreasonable refusal shows up.
Related
- § 5103 — acclamation, which requires a qualifying appeal route.
- § 5145 — the election action this article stands in front of.
- Inspecting association records — the other article with its own enforcement action.
- Board meetings — where the association's side of a dispute gets decided.